Is your retirement capital working as hard as it could?
Many retirement investors don't realize that certain self-directed IRAs can hold real estate-secured promissory notes. Learn how private lending works inside an IRA, its potential for interest income, and the important risks and rules to understand before investing.
Potential Interest Income Inside an IRA
IllustrativeSee how different principal amounts and hypothetical annual interest rates affect interest income.
Hypothetical illustration only. Assumes interest-only payments, a constant rate, and full, on-time payment for 12 months. Excludes fees, taxes, servicing costs, defaults, and losses. The rates shown are not offered or targeted rates, and this is not a guaranteed return, an investment offer, or a prediction. Amortizing loans and partial-note arrangements produce different cash flows.
What a self-directed IRA is
A self-directed IRA is a traditional or Roth IRA held by a custodian that permits "alternative" assets, such as real estate, private company interests, and promissory notes secured by real estate. The tax rules are the same as any other IRA. What's different is the range of investments the custodian allows.
Most IRAs at large brokerage firms can only hold publicly traded stocks, bonds and funds. To hold a private real estate note, your IRA generally needs to be with a self-directed IRA custodian that accepts that type of asset. Whether a particular note is eligible depends on the custodian's policies.
Your IRA is the lender, not you
When an IRA invests in a private note, the IRA makes the loan and the IRA receives the payments. Documents are titled to the custodian for your benefit, for example "[Custodian Name], Custodian FBO [Your Name] IRA." You direct the investment, but you don't personally hold it.
How your IRA makes a private loan
- Open a self-directed IRA with a custodian that permits private real estate notes.
- Fund it by transferring an existing IRA or rolling over an eligible retirement plan, such as a former employer's 401(k). A direct trustee-to-trustee transfer avoids withholding and the 60-day rollover rules.
- Review a specific opportunity with us and with your own advisors.
- Sign the custodian's direction of investment, instructing your custodian to fund the loan or note purchase.
- The custodian funds the investment through closing, and the note and recorded lien are titled in the IRA's name.
- Payments flow back into your IRA, where they can be reinvested or distributed under the normal IRA rules.
Potential tax advantages
Interest earned outside a retirement account is generally taxed as ordinary income each year. Inside an IRA, that changes:
- Traditional IRA: interest income generally grows tax-deferred, and is taxed when you take distributions.
- Roth IRA: interest income can grow tax-free, and qualified distributions are generally tax-free.
Straightforward interest from lending is generally not subject to unrelated business income tax inside an IRA, but certain structures can change that. Tax treatment depends on your circumstances. Please review any investment with your CPA or tax advisor; we don't provide tax advice.
Prohibited transactions and disqualified persons
The IRS bars an IRA from transacting with certain "disqualified persons." Breaking these rules can cause the entire IRA to be treated as distributed, with taxes and possibly penalties. Among other things, your IRA generally can't:
- Lend money to you, your spouse, your parents or grandparents, your children or grandchildren, or their spouses.
- Lend to a business you (or those family members) control, or to certain advisors and fiduciaries of the IRA.
- Make a loan that you personally guarantee, or that benefits you personally outside the IRA.
- Mix personal money and IRA money in the same investment without careful planning, or have you pay the IRA's expenses personally.
Your custodian doesn't judge whether a transaction is prohibited; that responsibility is yours. We encourage every IRA investor to confirm with their custodian and tax advisor that a proposed loan is permissible before funding.
Custodian fees, liquidity and required distributions
- Custodian fees. Self-directed custodians usually charge setup fees, annual account fees, and per-transaction fees for funding investments and processing payments. These come out of the IRA and reduce your net return.
- Liquidity. A private note can't be sold like a stock. Plan for IRA money in a note to stay committed for the full loan term.
- Required minimum distributions. Traditional IRAs generally require annual distributions starting at age 73 (75 for people born in 1960 or later). If much of your IRA is in illiquid notes, you'll need enough cash elsewhere in the IRA to cover them, or plan for an in-kind distribution.
- Valuation. Custodians typically require an annual fair market value for each private asset.
IRA investments aren't automatically protected from loss
Holding a note inside an IRA changes its tax treatment, not its risk. A private note in an IRA isn't FDIC-insured or guaranteed, and self-directed custodians generally don't evaluate or endorse the investments their clients choose. The same property, borrower and default risks described on our Collateral & Risk page apply in full.
Common questions
Can I use my 401(k)?
Funds in a former employer's 401(k) can often be rolled into a self-directed IRA. Money in your current employer's plan usually can't be moved while you still work there, though some plans allow it. Check with your plan administrator.
Do you recommend a specific custodian?
You choose your own custodian. On our call, we're happy to talk about what to look for, such as whether they accept real estate notes, their fee schedule and how they process payments, so you can compare options.
Can my IRA lend to a family member's property project?
Not if the family member is a disqualified person, such as a spouse, parent, child or grandchild. Lending to them is a prohibited transaction. Siblings, aunts, uncles and cousins aren't on the IRS list, but transactions that benefit you indirectly can still be prohibited, so get advice first.
What happens to my IRA's payments?
They're paid to your custodian and credited to your IRA. You can reinvest them or take distributions under the normal IRA rules. Payments should never be sent to you personally.
Take the details with you
Our free guide includes a full chapter on using a self-directed IRA, plus a due-diligence checklist to bring to any private lending conversation.
Download the Free Guide